Description
The incessant blaring of horns from the CSX trains going through the Lake Katrine area has gotten out of hand. Our residence is on Hallihan Hill and thus is not really close to the trains at all. We're now forced to sleep with ear plugs whenever the windows are opened. Has anyone approached CSX about installing horn technology that limits the horn sound to the track crossings and not project throughout the surrounding area?
63 Comments
K-town Insomniac (Guest)
anonYmous (Guest)
There is noise laws in place and for some reason these trains ignore them especially from 4a.m. till about 8a.m..I myself think its spite and CSX is gonna blast as hard as they want because they can .The steady blasting is outragious and why the are allowed is really out of control.Maybe the whole area should throw a law suit their way for the constant blasting.We all can live with a slight blast BUT THIS HASNT BEEN THE CASE FOR YEARS.
We live in Saugerties and not even close to tracks and in private woods and boy oh boy we hear it as well ......The county and people need to come together and force a change..funny how if ya have a party and it goes on after 10p.m. the noise level has to be trimmed down ok we got it ,,,but people are sleeping from 9p.m. through the night ...we got it ....but trains blast repeatedly ...through the night ...
The areas need to come together...
resident (Guest)
Former Resident (Guest)
Kevin (Guest)
wolsen (Guest)
Alicia (Guest)
rat1971 (Guest)
ULSTER JOHNNY (Guest)
Dee (Guest)
Hinchey, his flunky intern, or his drunk wife has nothing to do with this. Nor does CSX. The horns have been in effect since the trains were moving in the mid-nineteenth century. I took the Durango-Silverton steam train, and learned that the horn is truly a signal. This, from the Union Pacific website:
(= is for long sounds, 0 is for short sounds)
= = o =
Train is approaching public crossings at grade with engine in front. Signal starts not less than 15 seconds but not more than 20 seconds before reaching the crossing. If movement is 45 mph or greater, signal starts at or about the crossing sign, but not more than 1/4 mile before the crossing if there is no sign. Signal is prolonged or repeated until the engine completely occupies the crossing(s).
In addition, this signal is used when approaching private crossings if pedestrians or motor vehicles are at or near the crossing. (In the states of California, Idaho and Montana, the whistle is sounded at all crossings, public and private.)
Sorry folks - CSX isn't going to change the railroad industry for a town. Asking Hinchey's office to mail you information that doesn't exist is unfair. Of course CSX is going to tell you to "bugger off". This isn't their decision, either. It's the industry standard across the nation.
For more signals: http://www.uprr.com/aboutup/funfacts/signals.shtml
I live near the tracks, too (probably everyone in a river town does) and hear them as well. I guess I've gotten used to it over the years, but once I learned the signals, it's actually kind of cool to know what they're doing. My parents live on W. O'Reilly Street - pretty much right next to the tracks. They don't hear a thing because the horn isn't blowing near any crossing. As another poster wrote, the trains and tracks were here long before you bought your house.
Dee (Guest)
BTW, here's more from the website:
On April 27, 2005, the Federal Railroad Administration (FRA), which enforces rail safety regulations, published the Final Rule on the Use of Locomotive Horns at Highway-Rail Grade Crossings. Effective June 24, 2005, the Final Rule requires that locomotive horns be sounded at all public grade crossings 15-20 seconds before entering a crossing, but not more than one-quarter mile in advance.
The pattern for blowing the horn remains two long, one short, and one long sounding to be repeated as necessary until the locomotive clears the crossing. Locomotive engineers will retain the authority to vary this pattern as necessary for crossings in close proximity and will be allowed to sound the horn in emergency situations.
A ban on locomotive horns in Florida was ordered removed by the FRA after it was shown that the accident rate doubled during the ban. The new Final Rule preempts any state or local laws regarding the use of the train horn at public crossings. The Final Rule also provides public authorities the option to maintain and/or establish quiet zones provided certain supplemental or alternative safety measures are in place and the crossing accident rate meets FRA standards. Read more about the FRA Rule on the Use of Locomotive Horns.
ruserious (Guest)
Kingston Resident with a Brain (Guest)
ulster johnny (Guest)
annie (Guest)
K-town Insomniac (Guest)
Dee (Guest)
ulster johnny (Guest)
Dee (Guest)
Former Resident (Guest)
Emma (Registered User)
Hi all,
It's great to see SeeClickFix being used to voice your concerns about this issue. We think constructive conversation is good, especially when it's directed towards the identification and ultimate resolution of reported issues such as this one. That's why it's important to move the conversation forward as opposed to backwards. As a website designed to publicly address community issues, SeeClickFix would also like to emphasize the importance of respect on this forum. Comments that are attacking other users, contain harsh language, etc, are subject to removal by a SeeClickFix administrator.
As you continue your discussion, please let us know if there are any questions or concerns we can address for you. Our email is contact@seeclickfix.com
K-town Tea Partier! (Guest)
Maria (Guest)
Maria (Guest)
its like the horn is the conductors personality, some times its right on time and short and other times it is loud and really, really long.
the really, really long horn blowing does not make sense to me, it has no pattern.
K-town Tech Guru (Guest)
All you complainers just need to take the advice of Dee & her fans, and just move already! It can't be that difficult to walk away from your mortgage or come up with another security deposit; can it Dee? The choo-choo's were here first after all.
Hey, SeeClickFix - I think there's a bit of page formatting problem here, if you didn't notice. Do you have any IT people there who can take a look at it? I need to do some Report(ing) as Inappropriate.
Former Resident (Guest)
Former Resident (Guest)
Former Resident (Guest)
Emma (Registered User)
@Former Resident - As I previously explained, content that violates our Terms of Service is subject to removal by SeeClickFix administrators. This includes personal attacks, negative and/or harsh language, etc. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact us. I'd be more than happy to discuss this with you, as well as address any additional questions or concerns you may have.
@k-town tech guru - If you'd like to send us more information about the technical difficulties you're referring to, we'll pass it along to our tech team. contact (at) seeclickfix (dot) com.
Whatever (Guest)
Thanks, Former Resident.
Emma, how is it not a violation of your Terms when someone calls another user 'stupid', 'ignorant', and unintelligent - not to mention a few others. Seems a bit hypocritical...
As for the tech problems, the 'Report' icon/link is not contained within the dialogue boxes that contain text. Rather, it is appearing in separate, unpopulated, empty dialogue boxes. Hence, a page formatting problem. I'm running on IE8.
JD (Guest)
voice of reason (Guest)
JD is wrong. The horn doesn't need to be attached to the train.
And, it has gotten much worse in the last 5 years, perhaps AFTER you "chose a residence".
There is a simple solution other communities in NY have used to abate CSX complete disregard for the communities they operate in.
I think it's time to initiate it here.
Install a system (at CSX expense) that automatically blows short blasts of a horn, directed down the track in the direction the train is travelling, at a regulated decibel level, when the train is approaching an intersection.
Federal law requires a horn be sounded 4 times before passing through crossings. Often these horns are blown up to 10 times. At least make sounding the horn more than 4 a fine if no danger is present.
Also, I've noticed that the worst of it happens when they are switching or whatever they're doing when there are two sets of tracks. They blow the horns over and over and you can hear that the trains are barely moving or not moving at all. This use of the horn should be banned completely. I'm pretty sure they can use an alternative technology instead of using the horns to signal each other. Of course all of these types of movements happen in the dead of night.
The only way to get the ball rolling is having data. Information is power. Everyone with a noise issue should record the horn blasts that exceed the 4 through the intersection required by law. Keep a logbook with it. In six months the abuse wil be obvious. This information can then be submitted as evidence for the record at your local govt. meetings. Enough of this and some young politician will hopefully take the lead.
JD (Guest)
Railroads of CSX's size are interstate commisioned companies that provide a vaulable service to the economy of the United States. Provisions under the National Rail Act state that Class 1 Railroads only have to meet Federal Laws. State, County, and Municiple laws have no jurisdition when the concern how a railroad operates on its propery. Horns, speed of trains, etc are mandadted by the FRA (Federal Railroad Administration).
One solution is to have a "Quiet Zones" installed. A quiet zone is allowed only when every road crossing has been modified to not allow cars to get around the gates in any direction when a train is apporaching. Most of expense for this work is paid for by local, county or state funds due to the fact that the horn is a basic safety measure mandated by the FRA. All request for quiet zones have to also be approved by the Railroad and the Federal Railroad Administrarion. The FRA has denied "quiet zones" in the past for safety reasons even when the railroad has supported the idea. In addition, horns have to be blown at tresspassers and other CSX employess working along the tracks which I am sure make the problem seem worse.
- DMC (Guest)
voice of reason (Guest)
Yes JD, railroads are regulated by the FRA. Crossing required horn use is 4 blasts at 96 decibels. That is the only horn noise we should hear.
It is no longer 1850. The engineers don't need to use their stylized signaling so we all know who it is. The townfolk don't show up to greet the train as it delivers critically needed supplies to the town. Trains are not the primary means by which goods get to our area, or most areas, yet tracks run through the middle of almost every small city in the US.
Times have changed, and it seems time for a change in the way we approach noise pollution from this industry. The quiet zone boxes are cost prohibitive, which is why they are rarely used. The remaining alternative seems to be the most reasonable, giving a balance between the needs of the community, and the larger national need for thriving commerce.
Install an automated device to meet the requirement. It seems to me that the only thing we're really asking is for their engineers to stop using their horns and fulfill their boyish needs another way. No other industry gets to affect the quality of living for so many, without having to answer to the people of affected communities.
With CSX having gotten criticism for blocking all the intersections in town for the better part of an hour a few years ago (the Dunkin Donuts flap), one might think that we're being punished...
eleise (Guest)
The public is under a noise control ordinace and this nasty situation is no different .
Tracks a re meant for trains and when people cross the line lets say to beat the train .or kill themselves then thats what happens. No human belongs on the tracks period.
CSX doesnt care and doesnt do anything about their operators and as taxpayers we simply have the right to peace and quiet.We all know why they beep BUT IT IS OUT OF CONTROL PERIOD
ANNIE (Guest)
THE HORN TOOTING IS TO ALERT PEOPLE OF THE ONCOMING TRAIN... WHEN A TRAIN HITS SOMETHING OR SOMEONE IT PUT A LOT OF DEVASTATION ON THE ENGINEER.
I CAN ASSUME YOU HAVE NOT HAD THAT HAPPEN TO YOU OTHERWISE YOU WOULD NOT BE COMPLAINING NOW.
eleise (Guest)
IT DOES NOT ALLOW THEM TO A CONTINUOUD BLASTS ,BLASTS BLASTS AND SOME VERY LONG BLASTS
ESPECIALLY WELL INTO THE NIGHT
Public has to abide by noise ordinace control and CSX is way out of control and the publics feelings should be taken in account to when they do and knowingly lay on the horn for 30-45 seconds we the people arent complaining because were bored we also have rights .People live away from tracks yes AWAY and the pounding can be heard for MILES yes MILES .They have increased and this is WHY THE PUBLIC IS COMPLAINING.....
ANNIE (Guest)
ulster johnny (Guest)
ulster johnny (Guest)
eleise (Guest)
Considering your previous statements there isnt any sense in continuing on with your kind.
eleise (Guest)
You cant reach this kind of people it is best to ignore her.Click Fix is what it states A FIX and the light isnt on for her
ulster johnny (Guest)
ulster johnny (Guest)
ulster johnny (Guest)
u j supporter (Guest)
Emma (Registered User)
As I have previously explained, SeeClickFix utilizes a system that automatically moderates content for a number of reasons such as specific keywords and/or harsh language, content meant to attack other users, etc. The system also moderates content when the same user has posted frequently in a set amount of time as a way of preventing spam. We enforce our Terms of Service to ensure each users voice is heard and that the conversation remains constructive and respectful. Comments are posted once they have been reviewed if they do not violate. Our Terms of Service can be viewed here: http://seeclickfix.com/terms_of_use?print=true
If there are any questions about SeeClickFix, please let us know by emailing us at contact (at) seeclickfix (dot) com. We'd be happy to address them at length while keeping this issue focused on addressing your community.
midimax (Guest)
resident (Guest)
midimax (Guest)
M (Guest)
Did you happen to get any where with CSX? I live in Smyrna, GA- and the train tracks are right across the street from our home- and for the past 6 months the noise has become excruciatingly painful. I have called, e-mailed, called etc. I reached out to my city councilman- and he basically said we needed to call CSX and plant trees. The noise has gotten worse during this time because the train is now aloud to piggy back- putting pressure on the track- and they seem to be going faster and faster.
I am told by CSX there is a curve which is causing this- YES, but the curve was there 6 months ago when the train was not screaching like finger nails on a chalk board.
Folks hearing has been lost. property will not sel nor rent- which I would point to the train noise. CSX needs to be accountable. Let's video tape the noise and blast it in the backyard of the CSX president- and maybe they would get the point.
-Maggie
resident (Guest)
Kevin C. Wells (Guest)
ulsterjohnny (Guest)
midimax (Guest)
dhoover82 (Registered User)
Dave Christi (Registered User)
Signed. Stillusingearplugs😕
Jessica Negron (Registered User)
Luvleeroy (Registered User)
Highland (Registered User)
Highland (Registered User)
Dave Christi (Registered User)